Thanks for the quick reply.
1. “Front End PM Page” is set correctly in Dashboard > Front End PM PRO > Settings > General and that page has the correct shortcode and works as it is supposed to
2. Perhaps I am just missing it, but I don’t see any spot in FEP settings to specify the login page URL. Am I supposed to be checking this somewhere else in WP or my theme (OceanWP)? I am using the default wp-login.php for everything.